Do plastic bag bans work?

How charges and bans cut bag use and bag litter, where they leak into thicker bags, and why plastic keeps growing.

Plastic bag bans and charges work on bags: where use is measured they
have cut it by 81 to 98%, and bags' share of US shoreline litter by 25 to 47%.
Narrow bans that leave thicker bags free leak, and some of the plastic
comes back as bin liners. None of it has dented total plastic use,
which doubled between 2000 and 2019.

Bag bans work on bags, not on plastic

Plastic bag bans and charges work on bags when they cover thick bags as well as thin ones, and best when every bag carries a price. Where use has been measured, in England and Ireland, they cut the number of bags handed out by 81 to 98%, and in the US they cut bags’ share of shoreline litter by 25 to 47%159.

Bans that only cover thin bags leak: shops hand out thicker ones, and some of the plastic comes back as bin liners87. And none of it has dented plastic overall. The world’s plastic use doubled between 2000 and 2019 while bag rules spread6.

Over 7.5 billion fewer plastic bags a year

That's how many fewer single-use bags England's main supermarkets hand out now than in 2014, the year before the charge

England went from 140 bags a person to two

England’s bag charge worked. In 2014, the year before a 5p charge began, its main supermarkets handed out 7.64 billion single-use bags, about 140 for every person. In 2025–26, with the charge at 10p, they sold 126 million, about two a person1. The 2014 figure comes from WRAP, a waste charity, and was collected differently from the government’s later series; on the government’s own figures, sales by all 94 large retailers that reported fell 81% from the first full year of the charge to 399 million, about seven bags a person1.

That record rests on shrinking reporting. The number of retailers reporting fell from 261 to 94, small shops never had to report, and bags for life and paper bags are not counted1. England has no comparison group, only before and after, but the fall was large and came as soon as the charge did; the US studies below compare places with rules against places without.

Across the EU, where rules have been required since 2015, use of lightweight bags fell from 94.7 per person in 2018 to 64.1 in 2023, or 13 billion fewer bags a year23.

A small price on every bag beats a ban on thin ones

The mechanism is a price on something that used to be free. Denmark put a levy on bags in 1994 and halved their use5, but Ireland’s 2002 levy is the best-known case. Ireland measured what shoppers were willing to pay for a bag, set its levy six times higher, at 15 euro cents, ran a public campaign and paid the money into an environment fund. Use fell from about 328 bags a person a year to 21 within a year. When use crept back up to 31 bags a person, the government raised the levy to 22 cents in 20075.

Bans can miss. Chicago banned thin plastic bags, and shops switched to handing out thicker ones for free, each with about five times the plastic; the share of shoppers using a disposable bag did not change8. When the city replaced the ban with a 7-cent tax on every disposable bag, paper included, the share of shoppers leaving with a disposable bag fell by 33 percentage points: about half of them started bringing their own bag, and the other half carried their shopping out without one8. A 5-cent tax in Washington, DC, cut disposable-bag use by 42 points8.

California learned the same lesson more slowly. Its 2014 ban, upheld by voters in 2016, let shops sell thicker plastic bags as reusable, and in 2024 the state legislature found those bags “were not generally reused by consumers and resulted in an increased amount of plastic and plastic waste”; it banned them from 1 January 202612.

Fewer bags on US shores and the North Sea floor

Bags matter to ocean litter because they are common. Counted by item, they are the single most frequent piece of litter in the ocean, about 14% of all items11. Where it has been measured, bag rules have cut them, though that tells you little about ocean plastic as a whole. The evidence for even that much is recent.

"It is too early to draw robust conclusions on the environmental impact that bans and levies have had."
— UN Environment Programme, 2018

That gap has since been filled. In a 2025 study in Science, Papp and Oremus looked at 45,067 shoreline cleanups in the US and found that where bag rules applied, plastic bags made up 25 to 47% less of the litter than in places without them9. Seabed trawls around the UK from 1992 to 2017 found plastic bags declining in the Greater North Sea, against no trend in total plastic across the wider survey area10. On North-East Atlantic beaches, litter overall is falling, but its monitors call the decrease “rather small”16.

Some of the plastic comes back as bin liners

A ban that covers every bag still cuts plastic, though by less than the bag count suggests; a ban on thin bags alone can increase it, as Chicago’s did. Before California’s local bag bans, 12 to 22% of carryout bags were reused as bin liners. When the bans removed 40 million pounds of carryout bags a year, people bought 12 million pounds more bin bags7, so about 70% of the saving survived, by our arithmetic.

Economists call this leakage: plastic that escapes the rule into bags it doesn’t cover.

"policy evaluations that ignore leakage effects overstate the regulation's welfare gains."
— Rebecca Taylor, economist, 2019

Chile’s national ban removed about 249,000 tonnes of bags, while bin-liner use rose by more than half; a model of the change still found lower environmental impacts in 15 of 18 categories14. In the UK, supermarkets sold 1.58 billion plastic “bags for life” in 2019, according to a survey by campaign groups, a thicker bag outside the charge17.

A paper bag has to be used 43 times to beat plastic

Paper and cotton bags are not automatically better. Denmark’s environment agency compared them with a thin plastic bag that is reused once as a bin bag. On climate alone, a paper bag used once does as well. Across every environmental measure, a paper bag has to be used 43 times, and an organic cotton bag 20,000 times, to match it13. That study leaves out litter13, which is the harm this page measures bag rules by. It is one reason the rules that worked best, like Chicago’s tax, charge for paper bags as well.

127 countries regulate plastic bags, and half the results are unmeasured

By July 2018, the latest global count, 127 of 192 countries had some law on plastic bags: 83 banned giving them away free in shops, 61 banned making or importing them, and 30 charged shoppers a fee4. In half the cases the UN looked at, nobody had measured whether it worked5.

The rules have authors. Ireland’s environment ministry designed the levy that others copied, California’s voters upheld their state’s ban in 2016, and the EU gave every member state the option of making bags not free by the end of 20185123. Shops carried it through: in England, Tesco and Waitrose stopped selling single-use plastic bags from 2022–23, M&S and Sainsbury’s sold none in 2025–26, and retailers have given more than £234 million from the charge to good causes1.

Outside Europe and the US the results are mostly unmeasured. Kenya’s 2017 ban is one of the strictest, but the UN found no clear account of its impact5. Rwanda enforces its 2008 ban, while Uganda announced one four times without putting it in place15.

Bags are a small part of the plastic problem

Count bags and the rules look like a triumph; weigh them and they barely register. Bags are the most common item of ocean litter, yet a “small product stream” in a world that used 460 million tonnes of plastic in 2019, twice as much as in 2000, and let 22 million tonnes of it leak into the environment that year6.

"these measures focus on small product streams, which means that while they may reduce littering, they have less impact on total volumes in use."
— OECD, Global Plastics Outlook, 2022

Nobody measures how many plastic bags the world uses. The figure most often quoted, one to five trillion a year, comes from a 2018 UN report; its upper end traces back to a 2002 estimate once published on this website, and its lower end to an unrelated 2014 estimate5.

California’s thick-bag ban is the next test

The gains can slip. Italy’s use of lightweight bags rose from 93.1 per person in 2018 to 128.5 in 20232, and in England all reporting retailers sold 7% more bags in 2024–25 than the year before, before falling again1.

The EU average of 64.1 bags per person in 2023 is well short of the 40 its rules set for 20252. If it kept falling at its 2018–2023 pace, about six bags per person a year, it would reach roughly 52 in 2025, by our rough extrapolation rather than a forecast. The average also counts very light bags that countries may leave out of the target, so it overstates how far off some of them are3.

The next measurement to watch is California. From 1 January 2026 its shops can no longer sell thick plastic bags as reusable12, which makes the state a test of what Chicago’s tax suggested: that covering every bag is what makes a bag rule work. Ireland shows the other lever. Its law has allowed the levy to rise to €0.70 since 2011, so the price can go up again if use creeps back5.

How this number was made ▾
  • 7.64 bn (2014) → 126 million (2025–26), main retailers; 81% for all reporting retailers since 2016–17 england decline
    Three baselines, one publication. The 98% compares DEFRA's 2025–26 return with WRAP's 2014 figure (voluntary agreement, 6 of the 7 retailers), a different collection. The 90% and 81% use DEFRA's own series from the first full year of the charge, which already reflects the charge. Lead with the absolute figures; give 81% as the all-retailer change; say the 98% baseline comes from WRAP.
  • 328 before the levy, 21 within a year; 1.3 carrier bags per person in 2023 ireland bags per person
    Different definitions. The levy exempted produce 'knot bags'; Eurostat's <50 micron total (44.5) is almost all very lightweight produce bags (43.2 under 15 microns). The 15–49 micron class (1.3) is the one comparable to the carrier bags the levy targeted. The 328/21 figures are UNEP's summary of Convery et al. 2007 (paper not opened).
  • not used global bags per year
    No measured global figure exists. UNEP's upper bound cites Worldwatch 2002 ('Assuming that the number has remained stable') via theworldcounts.com's own legacy counter: circular. The page should say global bag use is not measured.
  • direction only uk seabed bags
    Paper paywalled; the 30% appears only in press coverage. Use the abstract's finding: bags the only plastic category with a negative trend while total plastic showed none.
  • about 30% offset by weight california net plastic
    Our arithmetic (12/40) on the paper's abstract figures; label as such.

Sources